Advertise on the Tentacle


| Guest Columnist | Harry M. Covert | Hayden Duke | Jason Miller | Ken Kellar | Patricia A. Kelly | Edward Lulie III | Cindy A. Rose | Richard B. Weldon Jr. | Brooke Winn |


Advertise on the Tentacle

June 30, 2017

Crime and Punishment

Ken Kellar

I came upon a surprising passage while reading the Russian novel Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky which was first published in 1866. I was reading it as one of those “must reads” that the intellectual elite tells us we should do.


Well in this case the elite was Canadian psychologist Jordan Peterson, who said the book had great discourses on the basis for morality. The protagonist conducts two senseless and horrible murders and the book centers on the murderer’s perspective.


A fourth of the way into the book, a new character tries to share his excitement regarding progress that the city of Petersburg appears to be displaying more than out in the country. Here the character seems to me to extoll the virtues of Adam Smith’s self-interested individual described in his 1776 work, The Wealth of Nations.


"Isn't it so?" Pyotr Petrovitch went on… "You must admit,"… "that there is an advance, or, as they say now, progress in the name of science and economic truth . . ."


“…Hitherto, for instance, if I were

told 'love thy neighbor/what came of it? It came to my tearing my

coat in half to share with my neighbor and we both

were left half naked. As a Russian proverb has it, 'catch

several hares and you won't catch one.' Science now tells us,

love yourself before all men, for everything in the world

rests on self-interest. You love yourself and manage your

own affairs properly and your coat remains whole. Economic truth adds that the better private affairs are organized

in society the more whole coats, so to say the firmer are

its foundations and the better is the common welfare organized too.

Therefore, in acquiring wealth solely and

exclusively for myself, I am acquiring so to speak, for all,

and helping to bring to pass my neighbor's getting a little

more than a torn coat; and that not from private, personal

liberality, but as a consequence of the general advance. The

idea is simple, but unhappily it has been a long time reaching us, being

hindered by idealism and sentimentality.

And yet it would seem to want very little wit to perceive

it . . ."


Had the Russian author Dostoevsky lived long enough to experience the Bolshevik revolution in 1917, he very likely would have been placed against a wall for writing the praises of free-market self-interest.


As it was, he was arrested in 1849 for belonging to a literary group that discussed banned books critical of "Tsarist Russia," was sentenced to death, but the sentence was commuted at the last moment. He spent four years in a Siberian prison camp, followed by six years of compulsory military service in exile. So, I guess Dostoevsky lived between a rock and a hard place.


I think the character Petrovitch’s statement fairly accurately captures Adam Smith’s assessment of self-interested business people benefiting the general population through their works.


The statement, however, seems to be too quick to cast away Christian doctrine regarding our relationship to others. Modern Christians find no conflict between their religious doctrine and free enterprise. They are arguably the most generous people on the planet. An impoverished third-world citizen might be more relatively generous when he gives me the shirt off his back, but that is all he can give. A prosperous American can and does give so much more.


I find it amazing to find a Russian, living under the fist of a Czar, in a country soon to be ravaged for generations by communism, writing on free market theory.


Oppressed Dostoevsky understood it, why don’t so many free Americans?


Yellow Cab
The Morning News Express with Bob Miller
The Covert Letter

Advertisers here do not necessarily agree or disagree with the opinions expressed by the individual columnist appearing on The Tentacle.

Each Article contained on this website is COPYRIGHTED by The Octopussm LLC. All rights reserved. No Part of this website and/or its contents may be reproduced or used in any form or by any means - graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, taping, or information storage and retrieval systems, without the expressed written permission of The Tentaclesm, and the individual authors. Pages may be printed for personal use, but may not be reproduced in any publication - electronic or printed - without the express written permission of The Tentaclesm; and the individual authors.

Site Developed & Hosted by The JaBITCo Group, Inc. For questions on site navigation or links please contact Webmaster.

The JaBITCo Group, Inc. is not responsible for any written articles or letters on this site.